Inside Stitch Coffee: A Canton Family's Mission to Brew Community

Meet the Hickey family behind Stitch Coffee on Reinhardt College Parkway—where five-bean blends, house-made treats, and genuine hospitality bring Canton together.

The Story Behind Stitch Coffee

When Dave and Geralyn Hickey moved to Canton from New Jersey a couple of years ago, they brought more than just their coffee expertise—they brought a mission. After selling their beloved New Jersey café, The Coffee Potter, they relocated to Cherokee County to be closer to their daughters, Sarah and Anna, who had already fallen in love with the area. The whole family decided this was the place they wanted to raise their families and put down roots.

The name "Stitch" isn't just catchy—it's a tribute to Canton's history as a cotton mill town, where stitching denim was a way of life. For the Hickeys, it represents their goal of stitching the community together, one carefully crafted cup at a time. They opened Stitch Coffee at 135 Reinhardt College Parkway in April 2025, and the shop has quickly become a gathering spot for neighbors throughout Canton.

What Makes Stitch Coffee Special

Take a look inside Stitch Coffee and you'll see what the Hickeys decided to be great at: customer service. Dave Hickey says their philosophy is simple—pick one thing to excel at and partner with the best for the rest. For them, that means focusing on genuine hospitality while serving award-winning Crimson Cup coffee, sourced through an ethical direct-trade program that supports coffee-growing communities around the world.

The coffee itself is a thoughtfully crafted five-bean signature blend from three major coffee regions—Central and South America, Indonesia, and Africa. Whether you're craving a classic espresso-based drink, a smooth cold brew, or something a little different like a Stitch Mocha or London Fog, the menu has you covered. They also offer smoothies and Italian sodas for those looking for a refreshing alternative.

The Menu: Local Flavors and Nostalgic Treats

Beyond the coffee, Stitch Coffee serves up house-made baked goods alongside breakfast and lunch options. You'll find fresh-baked treats like blueberry muffins and scones, savory breakfast burritos, and sandwich wraps from Southern Creamery in nearby Fairmount. The Hickeys also brought a taste of their New Jersey roots to Canton with Linda's Biscotti from Brooklyn, fresh New Yorker Bagels, and gluten-free, vegan Energy Bites.

Customers rave about the quality and variety—from the moist, flavorful pastries to the comfy seating that makes it easy to settle in with your laptop or catch up with friends. The space itself feels welcoming, with good lighting, 40 seats inside, and eight more outside for those perfect North Georgia mornings.

Hours and Community Spirit

Stitch Coffee is open Monday through Saturday from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Sundays from 7 a.m. to 3 p.m.—perfect for your morning routine, a midday break, or an afternoon pick-me-up. If you're curious about what your home is worth in this vibrant Canton neighborhood where local businesses like Stitch are thriving, that's a conversation worth having over coffee.

The Hickeys and their daughters run the day-to-day operations as a true family venture, and that warmth comes through in every interaction. It's the kind of place where the staff learns your name, where you can work for a few hours or just relax with a friend, and where the mission really is about connection. For more stories about what makes living in Canton special, explore more Canton guides on the blog.

Places like Stitch Coffee are part of what makes Canton feel like home—the kind of town where local, family-owned businesses aren't just serving great coffee, they're building something bigger. If you've been thinking about finding your own place in a community like this, I'd love to help you discover what's available in Canton and Cherokee County. Reach out anytime—let's talk about finding the perfect home where you can be part of this incredible local story.

Kate Valor is a real estate agent with Keller Williams Realty Partners, proudly serving Canton, Georgia, and the surrounding Cherokee County area. Whether you're buying or selling, Kate is here to help you navigate the local market with care and expertise.